15 September 2026
Leasehold Tribunal Advice: What Happens If Your RTM Claim Is Disputed | YourBuilding
Most Right to Manage claims go through without a fight. But if your freeholder disagrees that you're entitled to take over management, the case can end up in front of the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber). Here's what that actually involves.
When does an RTM case go to tribunal?
After your RTM company serves a claim notice (section 78), your freeholder has a set window to respond. If they accept it, management transfers on the date set out in the notice and that's the end of it. If they dispute your right to acquire management, they respond with a counter-notice (section 79) setting out their objection, usually challenging whether your building or your company meets the qualifying criteria.
If the freeholder won't withdraw their objection, your RTM company can apply to the First-tier Tribunal to have the dispute decided.
What the tribunal actually decides
The tribunal isn't there to referee every disagreement with your freeholder or managing agent. Its job is narrow: to decide whether your RTM company is legally entitled to take over management, based on the qualifying criteria in the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002. Complaints about service charges, poor management or building disrepair are separate matters and go through different routes.
Can you represent yourself?
Yes, and it's more common than people expect. The First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) is designed to be accessible without a solicitor. Panels typically include a legal member and often a valuer, procedure is simpler than civil court, and cases usually turn on straightforward factual questions such as floor areas, tenancy lengths or notice validity rather than complex legal argument. Many leaseholders successfully represent themselves and their RTM company at this stage.
What changed with the 2024 leasehold reforms
Since the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 changes took effect in March 2025, freeholders can no longer automatically recover their legal costs from leaseholders in RTM disputes. Previously, the risk of an open-ended legal bill was one of the biggest reasons leaseholders hesitated to pursue RTM when a freeholder pushed back. That barrier is now significantly reduced.
When it might be worth getting a solicitor
Self-representation works well for most straightforward eligibility disputes. It may be worth taking advice if the freeholder raises unusual legal arguments, if your building has complicated mixed-use elements, or if you'd simply rather have someone else handle the paperwork and hearing. It isn't a requirement, and most cases don't need one.
Where to get more help
For free, independent guidance on RTM disputes, LEASE (the Leasehold Advisory Service) is the official government-funded advice body. You can also read our RTM eligibility guide to check the qualifying criteria before a dispute arises.
This page is general information about how the tribunal process works, not legal advice on your specific case.
Related guides
What Is a Flat Management Company? | YourBuilding
Confused by the term 'flat management company'? We explain Resident Management Companies, RTM companies and managing agents, and how they differ.
Do You Need a Solicitor for Right to Manage? | YourBuilding
Most RTM claims do not need a solicitor. This guide explains when you can proceed without one, when you should consider getting legal advice, and what free support is available.
How to Serve an RTM Claim Notice | YourBuilding
A plain-English guide to the RTM claim notice - what it must contain, when to serve it, who to serve it on, and what happens next.
Ready to take control of your building?
Find out in minutes whether your building qualifies for Right to Manage — no solicitor needed.
Check if your building qualifies — free eligibility check